Legal Problems
Every newspaper, be it a magazine, a
bulletin or just a piece of paper, worthy of its name will
incur some number of problems with the Law. A good journalist
can never maintain he does his job well if there are no
arguments from time to time. We could not escape this rule
either. We received and feel obliged to publish the letter
below, sent to us by Mr Alfredo Versace´s legal
representative.
On behalf of and under responsibility of
Alfredo Versace, represented by the undersigned, I am inviting
you to publish the following. Following the publication of an
article dealing with a play by a certain Mr Lorenzo Lauria
with regard to a difficult contract of 3NT, I hereby inform
you that, due to an agreement by the parties involved, to any
difficult contract of 3NT made by Lauria and published
afterwards, there shall be a publication of an identical
contract, made by Versace. At this occasion, I have the
following material at your disposition:
|
|
Alfredo Versace,
Italy | Round 10, Italy v.
Belgium, Closed Room.
Board 8. Dealer West. None Vul.
|
|
ª Q 10 6 © 5 4 ¨ K 8 7 2 § A 8 7 3 |
ª 7 2 © A K J 7 ¨ A Q J 4 § K 9 5 |
|
ª K 9 8 5 3 © Q 10 9 ¨ 3 § J 10 6 2 |
|
ª A J 4 © 8 6 3 2 ¨ 10 9 6 5 § Q
4 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Versace |
Carcassonne |
Lauria |
Labaere |
2¨* |
Pass |
2©** |
Pass |
2ª |
Pass |
3§ |
Pass |
3NT |
All pass |
|
|
* 18/20 balanced |
** ª (who would have thought
that?) |
"Mrs. Valérie Carcassonne, North, unfortunately chose the only
suit for her lead that might make declarer´s life easy, when she put
the ¨2 on the table. This
card was covered a little all round, until it reached the queen
played by my client. After the time needed to make up his mind, my
client then crossed to a heart in dummy and led the §J, as he did not have the
advantage of seeing the opponents´cards. Had he led the §2, he would have shortened the
play of this hand considerably, but also have robbed us of a story.
The above-mentioned card was immediately covered by all, though it
would have been better had North left declarer on play with the
§K. North continued a heart
and Versace took all his winners in that suit, causing serious
discarding problems to the opponent in the North seat. She found
herself squeezed in three suits and, with the writing already on the
wall, decided to let go the ª6 and the ¨7. On the subsequent spade North played the
ª10, Versace put up the king
in dummy and Labaere won the trick with the ace. His return of a low
diamond was not covered by the declarer and North, left on play with
the ¨8, only delayed the end
of the play a little by exiting with a low club which ran round to
Versace´s §5. The subsequent
¨A then received the ¨K in his arms with pleasure and
the ¨J was the 9th
trick."
So much in defence of my client.
Yours truly,
M. Rosentrance Bridge&Bridge Solicitors
The New Guard
The retirement from international bridge of Pat Davies broke the
20 year partnership of her and Nicola Smith and the devolution of
the former GB teams forced apart Heather Dhondy of England and Liz
McGowan a Scot. It seemed sensible for Nicola and Heather to pair
up, and they are both in line for a genuine hat trick of three
consecutive wins, along with English Ladies team Captain, Jimmie
Arthur, a Scot. (As is Liz McGowan(
Two boards from their opening matches showed Nicola and Heather
to be in fine form.
England v Finland
Board 3. Dealer South. E/W Vul.
|
|
ª J 5 3 2 © 6 ¨ A K 9 8 2 § K 9 8 |
ª A Q 7 4 © A K J 7 ¨ Q 4 § Q 7 2 |
|
ª 10 9 8 6 © 9 5 3 ¨ J 10 3 § J 6 5 |
|
ª K © Q 10 8 4 2 ¨ 7 6 5 § A 10 4 3 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Dhondy |
Savolainen |
Smith |
Kulmala |
|
|
|
Pass |
1© |
Dble |
Pass |
INT |
All Pass |
|
|
|
First, Heather an obvious aficionado of Dad's Army, took Corporal
Jones catchphrase 'Don't Panic' to heart. That's where the
resemblance ended, for whereas Jones always did, Heather, on finding
an unfortunate continuation, kept her cool. ©K was followed by ª4, to the 2, 8 and king. Declarer ducked a
diamond to East's ten, and ©9
went to ©10 and ©J. Now Heather continued with
ª7, and as it would have been
consistent with the bidding for East to hold ªQ, declarer ducked in dummy. Three spades, three
hearts and a diamond were good enough to defeat the contract.
England v France
Board 8. Dealer West. None Vul.
|
|
ª Q 10 6 © 5 4 ¨ K 8 7 2 § A 8 7 3 |
ª 7 2 © A K J 7 ¨ A Q J 4 § K 9 5 |
|
ª K 9 8 5 3 © Q 10 9 ¨ 3 § J 10 6 2 |
|
ª A J 4 © 8 6 3 2 ¨ 10 9 6 5 § Q
4 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Fishpool |
Smith |
Hugon |
Dhondy |
1¨ |
Pass |
1ª |
Pass |
2NT |
Pass |
3§ |
Pass |
3© |
Pass |
3ª |
Pass |
3NT |
All Pass |
|
|
A low club lead from Nicola Smith was won by Catherine Fishpool
with the nine, and she continued with §K, then a third to Nicola's ace. Smith found the
killing switch to ªQ to ªK, and on winning with ªA, Heather Dhondy switched to a
diamond. On taking ¨Q with
¨K, Nicola cashed ª10, and a third spade to Dhondy's
ªJ spelt defeat.
Same Contract - Not
Quite
We heard of an unfortunate board for the Swedish Open team. It
comes from their Round 5 match against Austria.
Board 17. Dealer North. None
Vul. |
|
ª 2 © Q 10 6 5 4 3 2 ¨ 5 2 § A 9 7 |
ª 8 5 4 © A 9 7 ¨ K Q 9 8 3 § 6 3 |
|
ª 9 © K J 8 ¨ A 7 6 4 § K Q J 10 4 |
|
ª A K Q J 10 763 © - ¨ J 10 § 8 5 2 |
Both North players judged their hand to be worth a 3© opening - there the similarities
ended. The Austrian East player passed, which looks reasonable
enough. Tommy Gullberg responded 3ª (4ª
would not have been natural) and Lars Andersson rebid 3NT. It was
entirely possible that there would be nine winners but four losers
so Gullberg passed, hoping that 3NT would make while 4ª would not. His hopes were duly
realised. East made the normal lead of the king of clubs and
Andersson won and cashed eight spade winners; +400.
Plus 400 looked to be very good for the Swedes, but things went
rather differently in the other room. Again the opening bid was
3© but the Swedish East
ventured to overcall 3NT. Sitting South, Christian Terraneo of
Austria suspected that he had the beating of that contract and
doubled. Everyone passed with varying degrees of contentment and
Terraneo proceeded to cash all his spades then, in response to his
partner's discards, switched to a club; five down for -1100 and 12
IMPs to Austria.
If you want to have a good board, Tommy, you need a REALLY good
score at your table - +400 is nothing.
Miss (almost) no Mistake
By Ib Lundby
Dorthe Schaltz was the Danish player in 2000-2001 who won the
most national master points. Most of them she earned together with
her housebound Peter, but I guess that the gold points she won in
Open Pairs are the ones she appreciated most, because in that event
she was runner up together with her 17 years old son, Martin.
In Denmark's match against France in Round 9 (20-10) I kibitzed
Dorthe in the Open Room. In my opinion she didn't even touch a wrong
bid or a wrong card, but hand 14 was the exception:
Board 14. Dealer East. None
Vul. |
|
ª A J 4 2 © 6 2 ¨ 8 3 § A J 9 5 3 |
ª 10 8 3 © Q J 8 5 ¨ 7 6 4 § 8 4 2 |
|
ª K 7 6 © A K 9 3 ¨ A K Q 5 § 10 6 |
|
ª Q 9 5 © 10 7 4 ¨ J 10 9 2 § K Q
7 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Soulet |
Dorthe |
Abecassis |
Peter |
|
|
1¨ |
Pass |
Pass |
1ª |
Dble |
2ª |
All Pass |
|
|
|
The defence was perfect: ¨A, ¨K,
©A (©Q) and a low heart to ©J. A diamond from West forced North to ruff.
What now?
This was Dorthe's mistake: She cashed the ªA and played a spade towards dummy. Abecassis
ducked and ªQ won the trick
but left Dorthe with no chance at all though Abecassis on his side
of the screen twice showed an attitude as the hand was made (he
didn't expect his partner to have one more trump). One down.
The winning line: Instead of the ªA Dorthe should have played the ªJ and (when East ducked) continue
with a low spade towards the ªQ. This simple (sorry, Dorthe) play will succeed
with the spades 3-3 and the ªK with East.
In the closed room the defence was less accurate against the same
contract. East-West cashed only three red suit winners before
shifting to a club, and declarer had an easy task.
Hand of the Day
By Svend Novrup
It required perfect timing and drawing the correct conclusions
from the bidding to land 6©
on board 15 of round 9. Yoram Aviram from Israel stood up to this
challenge with one of the most brilliant pieces of declarer play we
have yet seen in these championships.
Round 9 Board 15. Dealer South.
N/S Vul. |
|
ª 10 8 5 3 © K 9 7 4 ¨ J 8 6 2 § 4 |
ª J 9 6 © - ¨ A K 9 5 4 3 § A Q 6 5 |
|
ª Q 7 4 2 © Q 6 3 ¨ Q 10 7 § J 8 2 |
|
ª A K © A J 10 8 5 2 ¨ - § K 10 9 7 3 |
Barel - Aviram N-S for Israel against Nanev - Mihov of
Bulgaria.
West |
North |
East |
South |
Nanev |
Barel |
Mihov |
Aviram |
|
|
|
1© |
2¨ |
3© |
Pass |
3NT |
4§ |
Pass |
5¨ |
Pass |
Pass |
5© |
Pass |
6© |
All Pass |
|
|
|
3© was preemptive while
3NT was a spade cue bid. South's pass of 5¨ was forcing, and when North did not double
South boldly bid one for the road and then had to justify hiss
decision in the play. |