France vs Italy
Open Series - Round 30
Thursday´s first match was scheduled to kick-off at 13.45 hrs.,
so the non-Seniors present here were supposed to enjoy a morning
off. In the programme, two matches drew attention: Norway v.
Bulgaria, possibly the opportunity for the latter to continue the
good work of the day before, and for the former an important match
as well, because a loss might result in Norway dropping out of the
top five again. The other interesting-looking match of course was
the derby between two of the all-time greats in European bridge:
France and Italy. Tradition has it that this match will always go on
Rama, no matter how the rest of the schedule looks like. Once again,
the decision to put this match on rama proved an excellent one. We
saw some wonderful bridge, but certainly the French would have
preferred to see a less one-sided match.
Session 30. Board 2. Dealer
East. N/S Vul. |
|
ª 7 5 3 2 © A Q 10 6 5 2 ¨ - § 8 6 5 |
ª Q J 10 © 9 ¨ A 9 8 7 § A Q 10 9 2 |
|
ª 6 © K J 7 4 ¨ J 6 3 2 § J 7 4 3 |
|
ª A K 9 8 4 © 8 3 ¨ K Q 10 5 4 § K |
Open Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
|
Pass |
1ª |
2§ |
4ª |
5§ |
5ª |
Dble |
All Pass |
|
|
This straightforward auction made it difficult for South to take
the right decision over 5§.
The contract went down two, 500 to Italy.
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
|
Pass |
1ª |
2§ |
4¨ |
5§ |
Dble |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Lorenzo Lauria had a subtle device at his disposal. Knowing about
partner´s shortness in diamonds, Versace had little trouble in going
for the penalty. Well done, Italy another +300 and the first 13
IMP´s.
In the Norway v. Bulgaria we saw the same two auctions. As
Helness too bid 4¨, the
Norwegians registered the same favourable swing as the
Italians.
Session 30. Board 5. Dealer
North. N/S Vul. |
|
ª Q © K Q J 9 7 4 ¨ 6 2 § J 10 5 4 |
ª A 9 8 7 6 4 © 10 8 ¨ K 9 8 § A K |
|
ª 3 2 © 6 2 ¨ J 7 5 4 3 § 8 7 3 2 |
|
ª K J 10 5 © A 5 3 ¨ A Q 10 § Q 9
6 |
Open Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
2© |
Pass |
2NT |
3ª |
4© |
All Pass |
|
Jean-Jacques Palau, France |
|
Maybe, Multon´s 4©
was a bit hasty. Had he passed, Quantin would no doubt have
doubled and the French would have collected a large penalty.
Note that only a diamond lead beats 4©, if played by North. France +620.
How to induce partner to lead a diamond? Boye Brogeland
found the solution. After Two hearts by North and Two Notrump
by South he simply overcalled 3¨. North bid Three Hearts, but now partner
came to life at what very much looked the wrong moment by
bidding Five Diamonds. South duly doubled this, but on less
than perfect defence Brogeland managed to collect eight
tricks. So -500 to go with +620 from the other table brought
Norway another 3-IMP swing.
|
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
2© |
Pass |
4© |
4ª |
Pass |
Pass |
Dble |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Look at the advantage of bidding 4© without further ado. Who would not bid, green
v. red, on the West hand? WRONG! You will get doubled for down five
and -1100. Italy another 10 IMP´s.
Session 30. Board 6. Dealer
East. E/W Vul. |
|
ª 6 © K 6 5 ¨ A 10 5 § A Q 10 5 4 2 |
ª Q 10 3 2 © Q J 10 7 3 ¨ 4 2 § 9 3 |
|
ª A K 7 5 4 © 9 4 2 ¨ 8 7 3 § K 6 |
|
ª J 9 8 © A 8 ¨ K Q J 9 6 § J 8 7 |
Open Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
|
Pass |
1¨ |
Pass |
2§ |
Pass |
2¨ |
Pass |
2© |
Pass |
3§ |
Pass |
3¨ |
Pass |
3© |
Pass |
3ª |
Pass |
3NT |
Pass |
4§ |
Pass |
4¨ |
Pass |
4NT |
Pass |
5ª |
Pass |
6§ |
All Pass |
|
Apparently, Quantin treated 4NT as RKC with diamonds as trumps.
Maybe, had he been able to respond with clubs as trumps, the slam on
a finesse would have been avoided. In a pairs event, six of a minor
down one would not be a dramatic result: if you get the ©Q lead against 3NT you are bound
to finesse the clubs for your contract, but it loses and you will
lose five more spades to go down two.
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
|
Pass |
1¨ |
Pass |
2§ |
Pass |
2¨ |
Pass |
3¨ |
Pass |
3© |
Dble |
Pass |
Pass |
3NT |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Here, a spade was led so the defenders took five tricks and there
it rested. The hand was a push after all.
On the next board, a brave double by Allegrini brought the French
a small gain instead of another huge loss:
Session 30. Board 7. Dealer
South. All Vul. |
|
ª K Q 9 2 © A J 9 ¨ 9 6 2 § A K 6 |
ª A 10 8 7 4 © K 10 6 3 2 ¨ 4 § J 5 |
|
ª 6 5 © Q 8 5 ¨ A K J 8 7 3 § 9 2 |
|
ª J 3 © 7 4 ¨ Q 10 5 § Q 10 8 7 4 3 |
Open Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
|
|
Pass |
2§ |
Dble |
Rdbl |
Pass |
2¨ |
Dble |
Pass |
3§ |
All Pass |
|
|
|
2§ showed both majors. The
contract went down one, Italy +100.
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
|
|
Pass |
3¨ |
Pass |
3© |
Pass |
Pass |
3NT |
Dble |
4§ |
All Pass |
|
|
|
3¨ showed both majors.
Lauria, holding the best hand around the table, had to take some
action when 3© came back to
him. He made a successful shot by bidding 3NT, but how could Versace
know? When Alfredo ran to 4§, +750 turned into -200. France off the mark
with 3 IMP´s where they could well have lost another 12.
Session 30. Board 10. Dealer
East. All Vul. |
|
ª A 8 7 5 3 © 9 5 2 ¨ J 10 5 § 9 6 |
ª J 10 9 © Q 4 ¨ K 2 § A K J 10 8 5 |
|
ª K 4 © A K J 7 ¨ A Q 9 6 4 3 § 4 |
|
ª Q 6 2 © 10 8 6 3 ¨ 8 7 § Q 7 3 2 |
Open Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
|
1¨ |
Pass |
1NT |
Pass |
2ª |
Pass |
3§ |
Pass |
3¨ |
Pass |
4¨ |
Pass |
4© |
Pass |
4NT |
Pass |
6¨ |
All Pass |
Forcing relay and good hand, after which a natural continuation
saw them reach the correct slam without much trouble. Italy
+1370.
In the Israel v. England match, the English reached 6¨ by West due to their system
agreements. Ophir Herbst hit the jackpot when he decided to lead a
low spade as North. Declarer ducked and who can blame him? Israel
+100 and a slam swing in their favour.
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
|
1¨ |
Pass |
2§ |
Pass |
2© |
Pass |
3§ |
Pass |
3¨ |
Pass |
4¨ |
Pass |
4ª |
Pass |
5§ |
Pass |
5¨ |
All Pass |
Either player might have done a little more here. France +620,
but another 13 IMP´s gone.
Session 30. Board 11. Dealer
South. None Vul. |
|
ª K 10 6 © 2 ¨ A K Q 9 8 5 2 § 7 3 |
ª 9 4 3 © K Q 7 5 4 ¨ 10 4 3 § 10 9 |
|
ª A 2 © A 10 8 ¨ J 7 § A K J 6 5 2 |
|
ª Q J 8 7 5 © J 9 6 3 ¨ 6 § Q 8 4 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
|
|
Pass |
Pass |
1¨ |
Dble |
1ª |
2© |
3¨ |
Dble |
Pass |
3© |
3ª |
4© |
Dble |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Guided by the double, Giorgio Duboin turned the play of this hand
into the highlight of the afternoon´s Rama session. An initial spade
lead probably defeats the contract, but quite understandably Multon
cashed two top diamonds first, before switching to a spade. Duboin
took the ace and advanced the +10, covered by South and won by the
queen in hand. Next came three rounds of clubs, Duboin ruffing out
South´s queen. Now the moment had come for the key play: the last
diamond from hand, on which dummy threw a spade! Multon won and
returned a fourth diamond, but Duboin could ruff this with the ace
(throwing a spade from hand) and play a club through South, ruffing
in hand to ruff his last spade with the eight and finishing off the
trump coup against South with another club. Italy a beautiful
+590.
In another match, Alain Labaere for Belgium showed how to make
4© without the help of a
double. North had opened and rebid diamonds and supported partner´s
spades. He led three top diamonds. Labaere ruffed the third diamond
with the ace and next ran the ©10 which held the trick. With the ªA still there as an entry, he
could afford now to ruff out the clubs and give South his trump
trick. After that, South, with only spades left, had to surrender.
Very well conceived indeed and a useful +420 to Belgium.
Back
now to our Rama match:
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
|
|
Pass |
Pass |
1¨ |
2§ |
Pass |
Pass |
3¨ |
Dble |
Pass |
4© |
All Pass |
|
|
Palau would have had some reason to copy Labaere´s line of play,
but when he ruffed the third diamond with the ©10 in dummy South could overruff and lead a
spade. With the side entry to the clubs gone, the contract could no
longer be made. Italy another +100 and 12 IMP´s.
Near the end, we saw the French close the gap a bit with some
useful partscore swings, until we reached the penultimate board. As
usual, this hand had been the first to be displayed in the Rama
Room, and it looked like a big swing to France. This is what had
happened:
Session 30. Board 19. Dealer
South. E/W Vul. |
|
ª K 8 3 2 © - ¨ A J 8 6 5 4 § A 3 2 |
ª Q 10 6 © A ¨ K 9 7 3 § Q J 9 8 6 |
|
ª 7 5 4 © K Q J 9 5 3 2 ¨ Q 2 § 4 |
|
ª A J 9 © 10 8 7 6 4 ¨ 10 § K 10 7 5 |
Open Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Multon |
Bocchi |
Quantin |
|
|
|
Pass |
1§ |
1¨ |
2¨ |
Pass |
2NT |
Dble |
4¨ |
Pass |
4© |
Pass |
Pass |
Dble |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Both 2¨ and 4¨ were transfers. 2NT refused
hearts but was forward-going, hence the jump to 4¨ by Bocchi.
For once in this match, the Italians were very much at the wrong
side of the score. On perfect defence, the contract went down three:
¨A, diamond ruff, ªA, ªJ to queen and king, §A (!) and another diamond ruff. Six tricks, 800
to France. To the Rama audience, it looked as if it would be a tense
match, but this did not quite come true.
Closed Room |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Palau |
Lauria |
Allegrini |
Versace |
|
|
|
Pass |
1§ |
1¨ |
3© |
Pass |
Pass |
Dble |
All Pass |
|
The same defence here as in the Open Room, but as the level was
not so high the damage was only 500. France +7 IMP´s. The final
score, however was 56-23 or 22-8 in V.P. to Italy. They were
catching up on Russia more and more, whereas France got further
behind the top five for the moment. |