Clash of the
Titans
Going into the fifth round of the A Swiss in the Open Teams, the
Lavazza and Reps teams were sitting high on the leader board – Reps
in second with 87 Victory Points, Lavazza fourth with 80. There was
considerable interest when the two teams were pitted against each
other.
At one table, Klaus Reps and Bernard Ludewig played against
Andrea Buratti and Massimo Lanzarotti, while Giorgio Duboin and
Norberto Bocchi for Lavazza faced Tomacz Gotard and Josef
Piekarek.
Board 1. Dealer North. None Vul. |
|
ª J 8 2 © 10 ¨ K 9 6 § A K J 10 9 5 |
ª
A 10 7 © K 9
7 5 3 ¨ Q J 8 7
2 § - |
|
ª
6 4 © 4
2 ¨ A 10 5
4 § Q 8 7 6 3 |
|
ª K Q 9 5 3 © A Q J 8 6 ¨ 3 § 4 2 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Gotard |
Bocchi |
Piekarek |
|
1§ |
Pass |
1ª |
2ª |
3§ |
3¨ |
3© |
Pass |
3ª |
Pass |
4ª |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Duboin’s 2ª showed hearts
and a minor. Piekarek took nearly half an hour to play this deal,
and all the thinking didn’t produce 10 tricks.
The ¨J (Rusinow) was
ducked all around, and a second diamond was ruffed by South. The
ªQ was ducked by West, but he
won the spade continuation with the ace and played a third round of
diamonds, again ruffed. South was now down to the singleton ªK.
Piekarek played a club to the ace (West discarded) and followed
with the ©10 to his ace. The
©Q was covered by the king
and ruffed with the ªJ, but
declarer was just about out of tricks. Indeed, he took only eight
tricks for two off.
South had an easier time at the other table.
West |
North |
East |
South |
Ludewig |
Buratti |
Reps |
Lanzarotti |
|
2§ |
Pass |
2ª |
3§ |
3ª |
4¨ |
4ª |
All Pass |
|
|
|
Ludewig got off to the lead of the ¨2 and Reps read the significance of it. He did
not, however, picture his partner with the ¨Q J. Declarer played low from dummy, and Reps
put up the ace, switching accurately to a club. Ludewig ruffed, but
it was too late for the defense. Ludewig got out with a low heart to
dummy’s 10, which held. A spade went to the king and ace and the
¨Q came back, but declarer
put up the king, pitching a heart, and played a spade to his queen.
That picked up trumps and he could claim from there for plus 420 and
11 IMPs to his team. Board 2 was a push, mainly because the
declarer at both tables mishandled trumps. It was tougher for Reps,
but Bocchi might have worked it out.
Board 2. Dealer East. N/S Vul. |
|
ª 8 5 4 3 2 © 4 ¨ 4 3 § J 10 7 5 4 |
ª
Q 10 © K J
3 ¨ K J 6 5
2 § K 6 2 |
|
ª
A K J 7 © A 9
8 5 2 ¨ Q § 9 8 3 |
|
ª 9 6 © Q 10 7 6 ¨ A 10 9 8 7 § A Q |
The contract at both tables was 4©. Against Bocchi, East, South led a low spade
to the 10, which held. South won the ¨A when Bocchi played low from dummy to his
queen – and South fired a diamond back. This seems to pinpoint the
length in diamonds (and provided a strong inference about the
location of the §A). South
would play a second round of diamonds only if he believed his
partner might ruff. Bocchi won, pitched a club from hand and played
a heart to the ace and a heart to the king. That was it – he had
three more losers for down one. At the other table, Lanzarotti
started with the ¨A and
followed with the ¨7, looking
a lot like a man who had started with a doubleton diamond. This made
Reps fear that if he played a heart to his ace and a heart to
dummy’s jack and it lost to a doubleton queen, North would then be
able to play another diamond, allowing South to make his ©10. So Reps won the diamond,
pitching a club from hand and played trumps as Bocchi had. Down one
and a push.
Another 10 IMPs went to Lavazza when Reps and Ludewig missed a
vulnerable game bid at the other table.
On this deal, the Italians fashioned a 1-IMP gain despite taking
a phantom sacrifice at one table.
Board 6. Dealer East. E/W Vul. |
|
ª 2 © Q 9 6 4 ¨ K Q 10 8 § A J 10 2 |
ª
K J 8 7 4 3 ©
J 8 7 ¨ A 3 § 7 5 |
|
ª
A Q 10 6 © A
10 3 2 ¨ 9
7 § Q 9 6 |
|
ª 9 5 © K 5 ¨ J 6 5 4 2 § K 8 4 3 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Ludewig |
Buratti |
Reps |
Lanzarotti |
|
|
1© |
Pass |
1ª |
Dble |
2ª |
Dble |
4ª |
Pass |
Pass |
4NT |
Pass |
5§ |
Dble |
All Pass |
As you can see, the defense would have to have a major breakdown
for Ludewig to take 10 tricks in spades with the East-West cards. It
was not so easy to tell that, however, so Lanzarotti took out some
insurance. Buratti had to guess well to avoid minus 300. Reps led
the ªA and continued the
suit. Buratti ruffed and played the ¨10 to Ludewig’s ace. A second diamond was
played, won in hand by Buratii, and he guessed the trump suit by
playing the §A and running
the jack through Reps. He conceded a heart from that point for one
down and minus 100.
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Gotard |
Bocchi |
Piekarek |
|
|
1§ |
Pass |
2ª |
Pass |
2NT |
Pass |
3ª |
All Pass |
|
|
Duboin’s 2ª showed a
six-card suit in a limited hand. 2NT was an inquiry, and the 3ª bid indicated 8 or 9 high-card
points with no shortage. Gotard’s silence seems conservative, but
the auction was considerably different at his table. In any event,
Duboin was in exactly the right spot. He won the opening lead of the
¨K with the ace, pulled
trumps and exited with a diamond. North won and pushed the §J through dummy. This held, and
two more rounds were played, Duboin ruffing. He now played the ©J, just the right card for the
layout. If North covered, Duboin could win the ace and exit a heart
to South’s king. With only minor suits left, South would have to
give him a ruff-sluff. If South unblocked the king, Duboin would
return to his hand with a spade to lead up to the ©10. Board 7 shows that even the top players
can lose focus on occasion.
Board 7. Dealer South. All Vul. |
|
ª Q 8 7 6 © K Q 10 9 ¨ Q 10 5 § Q 10 |
ª
A 10 9 5 © A
J 8 7 6 5 ¨
J § 9 7 |
|
ª
K J 2 ©
2 ¨ K 9 6 2 § A K 8 4 2 |
|
ª 4 3 © 4 3 ¨ A 8 7 4 3 § J 6 5 3 |
West |
North |
East |
South |
Duboin |
Gotard |
Bocchi |
Piekarek |
|
|
|
Pass |
1© |
Pass |
2§ |
Pass |
2© |
Pass |
2ª |
Pass |
2NT |
Pass |
3§ |
Pass |
3¨ |
Pass |
3NT |
All Pass |
Gotard started with the ©Q, taken by West with the ace. It’s usual to
duck holding the A J, but Gotard had reason to fear a diamond
switch. He played dummy’s top two clubs and exited with a low club
to South’s 5. West let go of the ©5 while North discarded the ¨5. When South cashed the §J, West pitched a heart and North the ¨10. A heart through declarer’s
jack produced two more tricks, and the ¨Q was covered by the king and ace. That was it
for the defense. One down – plus 100 for North-South.
West |
North |
East |
South |
Ludewig |
Buratti |
Reps |
Lanzarotti |
|
|
|
Pass |
1© |
Pass |
2§ |
Pass |
2¨ |
Pass |
2© |
Pass |
2ª |
Pass |
3NT |
All Pass |
2§ was an artificial game
force, 2© a relay and 2ª described a hand with four spades
and five hearts. South started with the ¨3 to the jack, queen and king (Reps thought
about ducking). Reps then cashed the §A and the §K, noting the fall of North’s queen and 10. He
did not notice, however, that South had played the §5 and the §6. Had he been paying attention, he would have
known that his §4,
insignificant as it might seem, was strong enough to knock out the
jack. Instead, Reps played the §2 and could only laugh at himself when
Lanzarotti played the 3 and North discarded.
Had Reps played the §4
instead of the 2, only a low diamond from South could defeat the
contract, assuming Reps played spades correctly, which was
likely.
In any event, one had had played the §2, there was not much Reps could do from
there. He won the heart switch with the ace and guessed the location
of the ªQ, but with the suit
splitting badly he had to settle for seven tricks and two down. That
was another 3 IMPs to Lavazza.
The Italians won the match in convincing fashion, 30-3 to move
into second place, while Reps dropped to fifth in the standings
after five matches. |